You’re getting married in the beautiful city of Naperville and you want a fantastic local caterer with the flavor and flair to delight your guests.
Choosing a caterer is an exciting decision, but a nerve-wracking one too. Weddings are expensive and catering is one of the most costly aspects of the day. A wrong decision here could turn your dream day into a nightmare!
You’re probably keen to make a decision, but you also want to make the right choice. Well, don’t worry. I’m here to help, and together we’ll find the ideal wedding caterer for your special day.
As a long-time Naperville resident, I’ve been to lots of weddings in the city and I’ve spoken with friends and family about their personal experiences with Naperville wedding caterers.
To help you make your decision, I’m going to tell you about eight of the best wedding caterers in Naperville and share my top tips for choosing the right caterer for you.
Naperville’s Finest Wedding Caterers
From value catering that doesn’t sacrifice quality to high-end options and international cuisines, these Naperville caterers are the best in the Chicago area.
1. My Chef Catering
My Chef Catering was established in 1989 by husband and wife duo Bill and Karen. From its roots as a gourmet deli and kitchen, the business has grown to be one of the leading wedding caterers near Naperville.
My Chef Catering changed hands in 2016 when Bill and Karen retired and experienced employees Dominick, Mark, and Megan took the helm. Under its new ownership, the caterer offers a variety of wedding menus and continues to receive glowing reviews and frequent awards. These accolades include a Best of Naperville award every year since 2018 and multiple Best of Weddings awards from The Knot.
At a Glance
- Location: 2772 Golfview Dr., Naperville, IL 60563
- Phone: 630-717-1167
- Email: [email protected]
- Website: mychef.com
- Price: $ – From $22 per entree
- Best for: Award-winning diverse dishes
2. Angeli’s Restaurant & Catering
Another Naperville wedding caterer with a long history, Angeli’s was founded in 1996 by Tony Angeli. Angeli’s began as a 40-seat restaurant, before expanding to a new 100-seat restaurant and adding event catering services.
From backyard weddings to 5000-person company picnics, Angeli’s has a track record of delivering exceptional events of all sizes. Their wedding menu offers plated, family-style, or buffet packages, as well as a bar and late-night snack service.
At a Glance
- Location: 1478 E Chicago Ave, Naperville, IL 60540
- Phone: 630-420-1370
- Email: [email protected]
- Website: angeliscatering.com
- Price: $$ – From $44.95 per person
- Best for: Large weddings
3. Belgio’s Catering
Belgio’s is a specialist in event catering, including weddings, private parties, and corporate events. Plated wedding packages range from $65pp to $85pp with a range of six different packages to choose from.
As well as delicious menu options, the company offers a wide range of wedding services, including wait staff and bar staff, wine service, china, silverware and glassware, napkins and tablecloths.
At a Glance
- Location: 416 W 5th Ave, Naperville, IL 60563
- Phone: 630-369-6100
- Email: [email protected]
- Website: belgios.com
- Price: $$ – From $65 per person
- Best for: Personal service
4. Anmol Catering & Events
Anmol is a South Asian eatery with a restaurant in Milwaukee and a new premises set to open in Naperville in 2024. However, the company isn’t limited to on-site dining. Anmol has also operated a thriving events and catering business for more than 25 years.
If you’re looking for something a bit different and you love Asian cuisine then Anmol may be the choice for you. As well as plated service, the caterer also offers a buffet menu and even ‘action stations’ where dishes are prepared live by skilled chefs as guests watch on.
At a Glance
- Location: 1550 Illinois Rte 59 Suite # 170, Naperville, IL 60563
- Phone: 833-462-6665
- Email: eatanmol.com/contact-anmol
- Website: eatanmol.com
- Price: $ – From $20 per person
- Best for: Asian, Halal
5. Chic Chef Catering
Chic Chef is a full-service catering company operating out of Addison but serving Naperville and the wider Chicago area.
Founded by Ravi Jayara in 2015, Chic Chef initially specialized in Indian weddings, but in recent years has expanded to cater for all occasions. The company was awarded a Wedding Wire Couple’s Choice Award in 2022 and 2023.
At a Glance
- Location: 401 Irmen Dr Suit D, Addison, IL 60101
- Phone: 630-589-9542
- Website: chicchefcatering.com
- Price: Available upon request
- Best for: Bespoke Packages
6. Tasty Catering
When you think of wedding cuisine, hot dogs probably aren’t the first thing that come to mind! But that is how Tasty Catering started out. From humble beginnings in the 1980s, serving Chicago-style hot dogs from their Tasty Dawg stand, Tasty Catering has evolved into a full-service catering company that employs over 200 people.
Tasty Catering is notable not just for its high culinary standards but as an employer and ethical business too. The company has an A+ rating from the Better Business Bureau and its accolades include making Forbes’ 2016 list of America’s Best Small Companies and Inc’s Best in Business.
At a Glance
- Location: 1900 Touhy Avenue, Elk Grove Village, Illinois, 60007
- Phone: 847-593-2000
- Email: [email protected]
- Website: tastycatering.com
- Price: Available upon request
- Best for: Awards and accreditation
7. Chef by Request
Chef by Request was founded in 1996 as a private party caterer and has gone from strength to strength ever since. The company has grown beyond simply catering for weddings and now offers a complete event planning service. That means they can help with your wedding flowers, entertainment, invitations, your photographer, and more.
The Chef by Request wedding menu can be prepared on-site or delivered to the wedding venue of your choice, which means you can enjoy first-class catering without being limited by the kitchen facilities at your chosen venue.
At a Glance
- Location: 5100 Academy Dr, Lisle, IL 60532
- Phone: 630-493-4300
- Email: chefbyrequest.com/contact
- Website: chefbyrequest.com
- Price: $$ – From $67 per person
- Best for: Complete event planning
8. Cocina Fusion
Cocina Fusion was founded by Anaxi and Juliana, a husband and wife team who promise to bring a delicious fusion of world cuisines to your special event.
Their unique menus include Latin and American fusion, Mexican, and Italian, while the services offered range from a full dinner service to interactive dining stations and late-night snacks.
If you’re looking to offer an unusual and memorable experience for your wedding guests then the interactive dinner stations could be a particularly good fit. The stations on offer include tacos, Argentinian, European, Colombian & Venezuelan, crepes, Puerto Rican, and Peruvian cuisine.
At a Glance
- Location: 1900 N Austin Ave., Chicago, IL 60639
- Phone: 773-430-4328
- Email: [email protected]
- Website: cocinafusionchicago.com
- Price: Available upon request
- Best for: World cuisines
Tips for Choosing Wedding Catering in Naperville, IL
There’s no single “best” caterer in Naperville – or anywhere else for that matter! – instead, it’s all about choosing the best caterer for you. Follow these tips to make the right choice.
- Consider your budget: You can discover the greatest wedding caterer in the world, but if their services are beyond your budget then there’s no point even considering them. Take care to choose a caterer that you can comfortably afford, and remember to leave some budget to spend on the rest of your special day!
- Think about your guests: A wedding day is about the bride and groom, but all of the wedding guests should have a good time too. While it may be tempting to choose your favorite cuisine, you should also consider whether the catering will suit the tastes and dietary requirements of your family and friends. After all, you won’t have a good time if your guests are left feeling hungry!
- Match your wedding style and theme: The catering you choose is just one aspect of your day. Your wedding will also be defined by your chosen venue, decor, music, dress code, and more. So, when choosing your catering, remember to think about how the food will complement other aspects of the occasion.
- Check their experience & reputation: The best way to choose a great caterer and avoid a wedding day disaster is to research what other events the company has catered and check their reputation. Do they have five-star reviews and positive word-of-mouth recommendations? Negative reviews – or no reviews at all – are a big risk and a sign you should consider looking elsewhere.
- Arrange a tasting: As delicious as a meal may sound on paper, there’s no substitute for sampling dishes for yourself. Be sure to arrange a wedding tasting where you and your partner can sample the food. My top tip is to check that the chef who prepares the food for your tasting is the same chef who will cook the food for your wedding day.
- Look for flexibility: Caterers will often have catered dozens or even hundreds of weddings and will usually offer set wedding packages. This helps keep costs down and saves you from deciding everything from scratch. However, no two weddings are the same and this is your special day. Your caterer should offer some degree of flexibility to suit your individual needs.
Final Words
Naperville is a fantastic wedding location with lots of wonderful venues and incredible caterers who will help to make your wedding a day to remember.
But of course, you want it to be a day to remember for the right reasons! Having something go wrong at your wedding can be devastating. Particularly if it’s something as important as the catering, which impacts every guest and has the potential to make or break the occasion.
Fortunately, you’re not alone in choosing your wedding caterer. By following our advice and recommendations, as well as reading reviews and arranging menu tastings, you’ll be able to book your caterer with confidence and look forward to your special day feeling safe in their hands.
